Tue Jul 11 20:10:32 EST 2006

Another Deep Thought comes from my MCSE book


Oh yes, this is another one of those earth shattering revelations that I simply could not have figured out on my own if the "Geniuses" at Microsoft didn't tell me. So, here we go...

As you probably know from a previous post I'm working on upgrading my MCSE from 2000 to 2003 as a requirement for work (it comes with a pay raise too which is my real motivation). I complained about the obvious nature of this book before but this one takes the cake so far. Check this out. I'm reading the chapter on Troubleshooting Software Deployed with Group Policy and they have a nice long table of Problem/Cause/Solution info to give you an idea of how to handle certain common situations. That's a good thing and all but when you get this it makes me raise my eyebrows and wonder just how good of a book this really is.
Problem: Published applications do not appear for the user in Add Or Remove Programs in Control Panel.

Cause: The User cannot access Active Directory.

Solution: Check to see whether the user can access Active Directory.
Why YES that's such a good idea! Tell you what, how about a couple of suggestions on why a user can't access AD and how to fix it? Why are we checking to see if a user can do something that we've already established that he can not do in the cause section!?

This isn't the only time this has happened. I have seen this kind of painfully obvious stuff several times so far and this one finally made me sick of it. Looking at the bios of the editors, Dan Holme and Orin Thomas, they sure look impressive with things like "10 Years Consulting" and "clients have included AT&T, Compaq, HP, Boeing, Home Depot and Intel". You'd think they would be better then this.

A tip to M$ here, if you are going to print books from your own publishing company about your own core products they had better damn well be the best books ever on the subject. I don't care if you are paying someone else to write these things for you. Try reviewing the thing before you publish. You are, after all, the creator and supposed highest authority of the products being discussed.

Posted by Brian | Permalink | Categories: Computers and Technology | |